DAILY CURRENT AFFAIRS IAS | UPSC Prelims and Mains Exam – 1st July – 2025
Archives (PRELIMS Focus) The Thali Index Category: ECONOMICS Context: Poverty estimates in India, sparked by household consumption data (2023–24) from the National Statistics Office. Reports from SBI and the World Bank suggest a significant drop in poverty. Decoding the context: Questioning Traditional Poverty Metrics: Critique poverty measurement based solely on calorie intake and physiological needs, calling it outdated and inadequate in capturing real-life deprivation. Introduction of the ‘Thali Index’: Propose the Thali Index as a more realistic, relatable, and region-specific indicator, measuring the cost of a basic home-cooked meal. It reflects actual food consumption patterns and regional variations in prices, offering a clearer picture of living costs. Relevance to Policy and Subsidies: The Thali Index serves as a practical tool for evaluating poverty and guiding food subsidy policies. It provides a grounded economic perspective by directly connecting food costs with livelihood realities. Critique of Premature Subsidy Removal: There should be caution against removing food subsidies based on optimistic or debatable poverty estimates. Instead, there should be rationalising subsidies, as many citizens still rely on them for basic sustenance. Policy Recommendation: Poverty assessment and welfare decisions should be anchored in real costs of living, like those captured by the Thali Index, rather than relying on abstract statistical estimates. Learning Corner: Poverty Measurement in India Poverty measurement in India has traditionally relied on household consumption expenditure surveys to estimate the proportion of people living below a defined poverty line. The focus has largely been on ensuring a minimum calorie intake necessary for survival and work. Traditional Approach (Calorie-based): Based on the Tendulkar Committee (2009) and Rangarajan Committee (2014). Defines poverty using a minimum daily caloric intake (e.g., 2400 kcal in rural, 2100 kcal in urban areas). The monetary poverty line is derived from the expenditure required to meet this intake. This is a physiological approach — focused on energy needs through food. Consumption Expenditure Surveys: Conducted by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) and NSO. Data is used to estimate poverty headcount ratios, consumption patterns, and economic inequality. Issues with the Current Method: Does not reflect nutritional quality, non-food needs, or regional variations. Ignores changing lifestyles, health costs, education, housing, etc. Urban and rural cost differences often not adequately captured. Emerging Approaches: Use of “Thali Index”: Cost of a simple, home-cooked meal (thali) to reflect real food expenditure and living standards. Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI): Used by NITI Aayog in line with UNDP — includes indicators like education, health, and living standards. Policy Implications: Recent claims of poverty decline (SBI & World Bank reports) raise questions on how poverty is defined. Critics argue for more realistic, consumption-linked, and multidimensional poverty assessment. Emphasis is shifting from calorie-based to livelihood and dignity-based measurements. Poverty estimation committees Tendulkar Committee (2009): Chairperson: Suresh D. Tendulkar Objective: To revise the methodology for poverty estimation in India. Key Features: Shifted from calorie-based poverty line to one based on actual private consumption expenditure, including health and education. Introduced a uniform poverty line basket for both rural and urban areas (earlier, calorie norms were different for each). Used 2004–05 NSS data and updated the poverty line accordingly. Recommended using Mixed Reference Period (MRP) for consumption data. Estimated poverty in 2004–05 as: Rural: 41.8% Urban: 25.7% Overall: 37.2% Significance: Marked a major methodological shift and was adopted by the Planning Commission until 2014. Faced criticism for setting a very low poverty line (₹33/day in urban areas in 2011–12). Rangarajan Committee (2014): Chairperson: C. Rangarajan Objective: To revisit the poverty estimation methodology due to criticisms of the Tendulkar Committee. Key Features: Restored calorie norms (2400 kcal rural, 2100 kcal urban) and added norms for protein and fat intake. Considered basic non-food expenses more comprehensively (education, housing, clothing, etc.). Based on 2011–12 NSS data, it set a higher poverty line: Rural: ₹32/day Urban: ₹47/day Estimated poverty in 2011–12 as: Rural: 30.9% Urban: 26.4% Overall: 29.5% Source: THE INDIAN EXPRESS India’s Secular Constitution Category: POLITY Context: Inclusion of the terms “secular” and “socialist” in the 42nd Constitutional Amendment (1976) during the Emergency. Key Points: Background: These terms were added through the 42nd Amendment by Indira Gandhi’s government and retained after the Janata government reversed most changes via the 44th Amendment (1978). Preamble & Secularism: The Preamble is a vision statement, but the Supreme Court in Berubari Union (1960) held it is not a source of power. Secularism, although added formally later, was always inherent in the Constitution — evident through Articles 14, 15, 16, and Directive Principles. Judicial Stand: Even before the 42nd Amendment, in Kesavananda Bharati (1973), the SC ruled that secularism is part of the Constitution’s basic structure. In Minerva Mills (1980), SC held “socialism” to be constitutionally aligned with Part IV (DPSPs). The SC reaffirmed secularism as a basic feature in later rulings, including SR Bommai (1994) and 2024’s Khanna ruling, stating constitutional amendments can’t dilute core principles like secularism. Learning Corner: Salient Features of the Indian Constitution The Indian Constitution, adopted on 26th November 1949 and enforced from 26th January 1950, is the supreme law of the land. It is known for combining the best features of major constitutions of the world while reflecting India’s unique socio-political context. Salient Features: Lengthiest Written Constitution Contains 470+ Articles, 12 Schedules, and numerous amendments. Includes detailed provisions for Union, States, Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles, and more. Drawn from Multiple Sources Inspired by British, US, Irish, Canadian, Australian and other constitutions. Blends parliamentary democracy with federalism and judicial independence. Federal System with Unitary Bias Division of powers between Centre and States (3 Lists: Union, State, Concurrent). During emergencies, the Centre becomes more powerful. Parliamentary Form of Government Based on the Westminster model. Real power lies with the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister. Secular State No official state religion. Equal treatment of all religions (Articles 25–28). Fundamental Rights and Duties Guarantees civil liberties to individuals (Articles 12–35). Fundamental Duties (Article 51A) added by the 42nd Amendment. Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSPs) Guidelines for the government to promote social and economic
DAILY CURRENT AFFAIRS IAS | UPSC Prelims and Mains Exam – 1st July – 2025 Read More »